If you're going to make a documentary whose whole purpose and method is to analyze another movie — in this case the documentary is Room 237 and the movie it digs into is The Shining — you'd better hope it's worthy of the art it dissects. If not, it will only make people yearn for that other thing that you are commenting upon and wind up kinda awkward, like a crappy sonnet about Shakespeare's genius or a mangled portrait of Picasso.
And man, I wanted to like Room 237. I went in hoping it would give me some new takes on Stanley Kubrick's horror classic. It doesn't, though, not really: Room 237 is either a bumbling ambassador for cinephilia or an unsatisfying examination of crackpottery in general. Either way, it's not good.
In its ambassador role, it's especially bad. The theories floated range from the merely possible (yes, indeed, I do see how you could think that the genocide of Native Americans was a subtle subtext) to the plainly nonsensical (no, I don't buy that the movie is Kubrick's response to guilt and/or marital problems arising from his participation in the staging of the moon landing).