Greg Olear, writing for The Weeklings, makes a good argument that Nick Carraway, the narrator of The Great Gatsby, is gay. I'm a sucker for unlikely theories about books and movies, but even more so when they rely on a close reading of the evidence. Also, since Baz Luhrmann's movie adaptation of The Great Gatsby is finally coming out this week, Olear's argument has gotten me thinking about the fundamental differences between the art of film and the art of writing.
Before I get to that, I'll have to convey to you the gist of Olear's argument, especially the way he uses Nick's point of view to make it. A big chunk of Olear's evidence comes from the way Carraway describes each of the other five major characters in the novel. Part of the argument comes from how Nick casts a pretty detached eye on the women, even though they are all supposed to be desirable in their own way. As an example, there is a passage where Nick describes Jordan Baker (a golfer), the woman he gets involved with: "She was a slender, small-breasted girl, with an erect carriage, which she accentuated by throwing her body backward at the shoulders like a young cadet." Olear summarizes it this way: "Other than the word small-breasted — which de-emphasizes the golfer's feminine attributes — this could be a description of a man."


