Showing posts with label movie diary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movie diary. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

the cow is sort of like an iranian lars and the real girl

Recently, as I watched one of the first great Iranian films, The Cow, which came out in 1969, I thought about this passage from Godfrey Cheshire's summary of the Iranian New Wave in a 1993 Film Comment article, talking about Close-Up (which I reviewed in an earlier post and which is possibly the best-known Iranian film of the past 30 years):

Here, after all, is a turbaned Iranian judge listening to impassioned arguments about the practice and value of cinema… . This is not the fearsome, dark-ages Iran of the 6 o'clock news, clearly. It is something far more complex, media-savvy, and oddly sophisticated, if be-turbaned still.

Cheshire spends the rest of the article talking about that sophistication and the subtlety of Iranian films, but the message I take from this passage is that anything "oddly sophisticated" coming out of anybody with a turban is a small miracle in itself. I kind of felt the same way, to be honest, but, at the same time, I think my surprise at finding out I was wrong is the oddest thing, not the sophistication that it turns out Iranian culture could exhibit. Look, I have prejudices and biases, but when they're proven wrong, I hope my reaction wouldn't be to take them as logical or any counter-evidence as paradoxical. It's not really a surprise when other cultures, even ones with strong conservative political or cultural strains, produce amazing cinema.

Friday, August 23, 2013

invasion of the body snatchers: no, seriously, what's with the half-glove?

I spent all of my last post criticizing Room 237 for proposing many untenable theories about the hidden meanings behind The Shining. Today, to completely contradict myself, I'm going to propose my own untenable theory about the 1978 remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers.

(BTW, I watched Body Snatchers this week specifically because director Edgar Wright mentioned that it was a big inspiration for his new movie, The World's End.)

To wit, my theory is that you can read almost all of Body Snatchers as the protagonists' shared paranoid delusions and not an actual alien invasion. I'll just say up front that I know perfectly well it's a bit of an awkward fit to the movie, but it explains a surprising amount. More importantly, if you read the film this way, it explains a lot about the tone.

Friday, August 16, 2013

ambassador crackpot: room 237, the shining, and slacker

If you're going to make a documentary whose whole purpose and method is to analyze another movie — in this case the documentary is Room 237 and the movie it digs into is The Shining — you'd better hope it's worthy of the art it dissects. If not, it will only make people yearn for that other thing that you are commenting upon and wind up kinda awkward, like a crappy sonnet about Shakespeare's genius or a mangled portrait of Picasso.

And man, I wanted to like Room 237. I went in hoping it would give me some new takes on Stanley Kubrick's horror classic. It doesn't, though, not really: Room 237 is either a bumbling ambassador for cinephilia or an unsatisfying examination of crackpottery in general. Either way, it's not good.

In its ambassador role, it's especially bad. The theories floated range from the merely possible (yes, indeed, I do see how you could think that the genocide of Native Americans was a subtle subtext) to the plainly nonsensical (no, I don't buy that the movie is Kubrick's response to guilt and/or marital problems arising from his participation in the staging of the moon landing).

Friday, July 26, 2013

the flimsy, sad future of bartholomew's song

IMDB.com estimates that Bartholomew's Song cost $2,500, a figure that's been rattling around in my head while I've been thinking how damn good it is. The short is only about 10 minutes long, but the directors, Lowell Frank and Destin Daniel Cretton, have made a virtue out of a low budget and a brief run time.

B.'s Song takes place in a dystopia where workers sleep in cell-like rooms and assemble little cubic things at an absurdly slow rate. Life for Bartholomew 467 and his fellow Bartholomews (it seems that every man is named Bartholomew) is monotonous and comically repetitive, but their blank faces suggest that this isn't generally a problem.

This is a good world to set a cheap short in, because that basic premise can be established in only six static shots that begin Song. The simplicity of the shots echoes the mechanical, modular quality of the Bartholomews' world, where everything is as discreet and functional as the cogs of a pocket watch.

Friday, July 19, 2013

the psychopathology of lying and/or filmmaking in kiarostami's close-up

If I'm going to talk about Close-Up, the 1990 film by Abbas Kiarostami (pretty much Iran's most lauded filmmaker), I'm going to have to talk about a bunch of things I don't actually want to talk about before I can get to what actually interests me.

That's because I only engaged half-heartedly with the film's biggest idea: Close-Up's main thematic strand is the the process and illusion of cinema itself and the artificiality of the movie-making process. The film stems from the story of Hossein Sabzian, an Iranian who (in real life) passed himself off as well-known filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf to a Tehran family of some means, the Ahankhahs. (As an American, I don't know how classy they were by the standards of Iran in 1990, but they have a kempt house and a gated courtyard.)

Sabzian was arrested after his lie was uncovered, and a large chunk of the movie consists of his trial, in the form of a documentary. This footage is interlarded with stagings of his interactions with the Ahankhahs — which, strangely, are acted out by Sabzian and the family themselves. In fact, as Godfrey Cheshire explains in his Criterion essay on the film, "Contrary to what most first-time viewers assume, none of its scenes are strictly documentary. Not just the reenactments but all the other scenes, too, are at least partly scripted or otherwise contrived by Kiarostami."

Friday, July 5, 2013

mirror mirror: shrek with (too much?) ambition

I watched another movie by Tarsem Singh this week, Mirror Mirror. He also directed Immortals, which I wrote about a couple of months ago. I like to write about outliers, and Singh's movies are vivid and cinematic in a way that most modern Hollywood directors don't bother with. Think Avatar but with arty intentions and even richer detail.

Mirror Mirror is a retelling of Snow White, which saves me the trouble of summarizing the plot. Suffice it to say that in this version the seven dwarves are thieves with a hideout. To get what I meant by "vivid" above, take a look at this screen grab of their den:

Check out the meticulously arranged mess in the front there. It looks like the perfect still life, and I suspect it's a visual reference to some classic painting I don't know, but in any event, the shot gives you a sense of what the movie is like: lots and lots of texture. This is a film where the bandit hideout has elegant, patterned wallpaper. (Look at the background of that screen grab and you'll see a sort of Japanese engraving sort of motif.)

Friday, June 28, 2013

hats of the damned: pasolini's oedipus rex

I suppose I came to Pier Paolo Pasolini's film version of Oedipus Rex hoping that it would work with the meaning I had gotten out of the play, which I analyzed in some depth a few weeks ago. My conclusion was basically that Sophocles' original play works best if we think of it as a parable about the sin we do unknowingly and the dangers of knowledge.

Pasolini's film, however, doesn't really focus on these aspects, or at least not in any way I can tell, and I'm kind of unsure what to make of it overall. The movie's major innovation is that it begins and ends in 20th century Italy. In some early part of the 20th century (I can't figure out what year exactly this would have been), Pasolini shows us a young military man who is jealous of the attention his wife pays to their infant son. Shortly, the setting changes to ancient Greece and tells us the traditional story of Oedipus in chronological order (as opposed to the play, where Oedipus is already king and we only learn of his true back story through exposition). Then, where the play would end with Oedipus blind and shamed, the movie magically transposes the same actor to 1970s Italy, making him a blind beggar.

Thursday, June 20, 2013

the cinematography of la dolce vita: that's deep, man

I've got an essay coming on La Dolce Vita for the Brattle Theatre Film Notes blog — I'll add a link when they put it up. The Brattle Theatre's Film Notes blog just posted my essay about La Dolce Vita, but I also wanted to post these great screen grabs that show how damn satisfying the cinematography is and the incredible use of depth.

If you want the tl;dr version of this post, just look at these two compositions, which are the opening shots of their respective scenes:

Either one of these shots is near-perfect on its own, but they're even better put side by side like this, because you can see the echoes: The top one is almost all white, the bottom almost all black; the top shot has a vanishing point somewhere on the right half; the bottom's is at approximately the mirror point on the left.

Friday, June 14, 2013

i need to stop writing this post before i convince myself that sucker punch is actually brilliant

Man of Steel, Zack Snyder's new Superman movie, is coming out this weekend. I'm going to use that as a reason to write about Sucker Punch, his last movie, because I've been wanting to write about this hot mess ever since it came out two years ago.

Although it's probably not very good in the final analysis, Sucker Punch plays with a lot of smart ideas, including an ironic self-awareness that most blockbuster action directors never mess with. In case you're wondering if I'm just trying to find something complex about this movie, worry not: This self-consciousness is plainly implied by the movie itself, and even if Snyder can't really figure out what that means or what to do with it, I like that he tried.

We're immediately put on notice by the first image, a slow crawl forward through a theater that moves toward a curtain with the Warner Bros. logo on it. That curtain opens up onto another curtain with the production company's logo, which in turn opens directly onto the first scene. In this very first image, then, we are being given a staged scene that is patently artificial, since of course we don't normally watch the action of a movie take place on a theater stage unless it happens to take place in a theater. It's the film equivalent of breaking the fourth wall.

Friday, May 31, 2013

leviathan has a really subtle point if i think really hard about it

Last year, the New York Times ran a profile of the filmmakers behind Leviathan, which I just saw on Monday. Here's how the profile began:

Tucked within the syllabus for a class that the filmmaker and anthropologist Lucien Castaing-Taylor teaches at Harvard is a rhetorical question that sums up his view of nonfiction film: "If life is messy and unpredictable, and documentary is a reflection of life, should it not be digressive and open-ended too?"

Just so you know, I cannot in good conscience recommend Leviathan, as I was tempted to walk out of the theater due to boredom. That said, this aphorism from Castaing-Taylor does not even make the best case for the film, and of the reviews I've read, I haven't seen anybody else do it, either.

Friday, May 24, 2013

the squid and the whale: noah baumbach's human new york

In principle, at least, I'm skeptical of any movie about worrisome white New Yorkers of the creative or professional persuasion. There are too many movies about them, and too often you suspect they're just the filmmakers' somewhat idealized narratives of their own lives. Woody Allen has almost single-handedly created an excess supply of this genre, and he's not alone.

Noah Baumbach, who directed the new Frances Ha, would be part of the problem if the movies I've seen by him — The Squid and the Whale, Greenberg, and Margot at the Wedding — weren't wonderful. I rewatched The Squid and the Whale this week to figure out why I wanted to give it a pass even though it has the aforementioned New York Problem.

Part of what I like about Baumbach's stuff is that his movies deglamorize their New Yorker subjects, those frowny-faced writers, professors, and would-be artists who are made out to be the objects of sympathy in lesser movies. Baumbach has worked with Wes Anderson on several projects, and like Anderson's characters, Baumbach's people are can be positively craptastic to one another, at least occasionally. On the commentary of the "Special Edition" DVD of The Squid and the Whale, Baumbach puts it this way: "People would say, 'Well, where is the redemption of the character?' and I would answer, somewhat smugly, 'Not in this movie.'"

Friday, April 26, 2013

dimensions of confusion in primer, upstream color, and mulholland drive

I caught Upstream Color a couple of weeks ago. It's the latest movie by the writer/director/actor Shane Carruth, whose previous film was Primer, from 2004.

For the first hour or so, Primer is comprehensible: It's about time travel, yes, and it often seems like Carruth is purposely confusing you, yes, but still, you can keep its logic straight, depending on how much mental RAM you have and, of course, depending on how much you actually care. I watched it for the second time over the weekend and found that it wasn't until very near the end of the first hour that things got confusing.

But "confusing" doesn't really do justice to the subsequent disorientation. Primer gets utterly mind-boggling, and quickly, to the point that within 10 minutes you're not even sure the film is logical, but you can't prove it because it's so hard to figure out what's happening.

Friday, April 19, 2013

don't be turned off by raccoon mario: a very half-hearted case for immortals

I'm sure a lot of people saw the trailer for Immortals and dismissed it as a sword-and-sandals deal that would be about the joy of spearing your enemy and not much else, but this one is significantly more artistically ambitious than the average Conan movie. I like that Immortals takes risks, even when it results in costumes like this, which I think of as "Edgy Raccoon Mario":

It's easy to take shots at this movie, but actually the willingness to embrace unique visuals pays off in some beautiful moments. The single best part from this perspective is probably the climatic battle between Zeus's cohort of gods and their nemeses, the Titans. (Titans, like all creepy things, stoop a lot for reasons that are unclear.) It begins when Zeus and the other four Olympian gods arrive on earth by dropping in as clouds of gold dust — very heavy gold dust, apparently, because they come in at a fast rate — and they materialize upon hitting the ground. Each landing makes a sound like a metal door being clanged shut, as if they were iron statues dropped to earth, and the camera even shudders a little bit, as if being shaken by the impact. It's a great effect.

Friday, April 12, 2013

the opaque camera in boudu saved from drowning

I've seen three films by Jean Renoir at this point, and I'd rather not say it, but to tell the truth I don't get why he's revered among directors.

The first two that I saw were the ones he's best known for, Grand Illusion and The Rules of the Game, and I didn't dislike them so much as I didn't understand why I needed to watch them. I'll use a painfully vague term on the condition that I promise I won't get in the habit: Both movies seemed a bit unfocused to me.

And so it is with this most recent film of his that I've just seen, Boudu Saved From Drowning, from 1932. Boudu is homeless and living in Paris. After losing his dog, he wanders a bit, seeming not particularly to have any emotion about the loss. And then, wandering across a bridge, he walks to the railing and jumps off into the water. With a telescope, a Monsieur Lestingois sees this and rushes from his nearby bookstore to jump in the river and save Boudu. After a kind of CPR that looks suspiciously like forcing the victim to do calisthenics, Lestingois succeeds in reviving the tramp, and now the bourgeois bookseller feels compelled to look after him. Boudu effectively becomes an unwilling member of the household, joining the aging Lestingois, his wife, and their maid — who is also the older man's mistress.

Friday, April 5, 2013

spring breakers: pathological innocence

I was thinking that Spring Breakers was going to be a certain kind of film. The trailer is all about glossy beach bodies and neon colors and sex and violence, and I assumed the movie would rub my nose in sensationalism, in a kind of cinematic equivalent of saying, "Hey, aren't you cheap for enjoying this lurid stuff?"

I don't suspect this of all lurid movies — some movies are merely tawdry, not self-consciously tawdry in a way that suggests the director is messing with you. But the last film by Breakers' writer-director, Harmony Korine, was a movie about people dressed in completely unconvincing old-people masks and humping trash. Its title was "Trash Humpers." I didn't see it because it looked as though its entire raison d'ĂȘtre was to make me uncomfortable and probably bored.

Friday, March 8, 2013

weird by design vs. weird by accident: stoker and shadow of a doubt

Last weekend at the theater I saw Stoker, which was inspired by Hitchcock's Shadow of a Doubt .

Shadow of a Doubt's big contribution to Stoker is the general set-up and dynamic: Both movies kick off with a character named "Uncle Charlie" moving in with a young woman and her family, and in both movies the guy turns out to be a supercreep.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

everything you need to know about the difference between house of cards and the west wing, you can see in the opening credits

I will admit, it's reductive to measure a show by the credit sequence that it begins with. But it's not my fault that House of Cards and The West Wing can actually be meaningfully compared therein, even if you can't completely encapsulate them in those few seconds.

With many shows, I feel like the opening credits are a quick look into how the producers would like you to think of the program, since it's one of their few chances to deliver a context-free montage that is all about tone and nothing else. This was a problem for me with one particular program, Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip (which, like The West Wing, was a creation of Aaron Sorkin). I liked Studio 60 overall, but the few seconds that the title appeared onscreen were unnerving. Nothing about the show matched that sequence's short burst of jazzy sax, coming on like a fragment of watered-down sleaze that had gotten lost on its way from a Vegas elevator to the world's worst nightclub. (For the strong-stomached, you can see what I'm talking about below just after 3:40.)

Friday, February 22, 2013

germany year zero: a heap of rubble can be fascinating when you know it used to be a city

I finally finished Germany Year Zero yesterday, a Netflix DVD I've had so long I literally refuse to check my queue to see how long I've been sitting on it.

It's the third part of Roberto Rossellini's "War Trilogy," the second part of which, Paisan, bowled me over. Germany Year Zero, however, well, not so much. I've been having trouble figuring out why, since the two movies are mighty similar. For one, in the blatantly obvious category, there are the settings: Shot in Germany and Italy soon after the end of World War II, both movies show you the real bombed-out cityscapes, crumbling versions of Berlin, Florence, Rome, etc., that are halfway back to nature. This falling apart has a magical effect. When a building begins to resemble a pile of bricks more than a school, a factory, or whatever workaday government office it was before, it reminds us that whatever we took for granted there as a social institution would only last as long as society itself does.

Monday, February 4, 2013

some blathering re: silver linings playbook, wherein i validate the swoopy cam of david o. russell

It's hard to pinpoint why David O. Russell's movies are so good. He tends to do projects that could be described in generic terms, but then he does a version that seems to transcendent the genre. The Fighter is a great sports movie, Three Kings is a war movie that makes the whole war movie thing seem fresh, and Flirting with Disaster might be my single favorite rom-com.

So I recently checked out Russell's Silver Linings Playbook, even though the previews made it look like a somewhat rote drama. Though the story was middling, the acting justified the attention (though maybe not the Oscar noms). Bradley Cooper doesn't overplay the whole bipolar thing, and in one scene Jennifer Lawrence convincingly stares down Robert De Niro (also great), which is nothing to sneeze at.

But the aspect worth the most analysis hasn't really gotten much notice at all, as far as I can see.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

more waltz: why are parallels so satisfying?

That scene I blogged about last week from early in Take This Waltz? Totally referenced later in the same film. To the screen shots!

The top shot is the early nighttime scene, and the bottom is the later daytime scene that comes near the end of the movie. The compositions are a near match, and by starting the second scene this way, director Sarah Polley is practically telegraphing to us that we should be on the lookout for parallels (which are even easier to spot if you've already written a blog post about the earlier scene).