Showing posts with label metalogue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label metalogue. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

the cow is sort of like an iranian lars and the real girl

Recently, as I watched one of the first great Iranian films, The Cow, which came out in 1969, I thought about this passage from Godfrey Cheshire's summary of the Iranian New Wave in a 1993 Film Comment article, talking about Close-Up (which I reviewed in an earlier post and which is possibly the best-known Iranian film of the past 30 years):

Here, after all, is a turbaned Iranian judge listening to impassioned arguments about the practice and value of cinema… . This is not the fearsome, dark-ages Iran of the 6 o'clock news, clearly. It is something far more complex, media-savvy, and oddly sophisticated, if be-turbaned still.

Cheshire spends the rest of the article talking about that sophistication and the subtlety of Iranian films, but the message I take from this passage is that anything "oddly sophisticated" coming out of anybody with a turban is a small miracle in itself. I kind of felt the same way, to be honest, but, at the same time, I think my surprise at finding out I was wrong is the oddest thing, not the sophistication that it turns out Iranian culture could exhibit. Look, I have prejudices and biases, but when they're proven wrong, I hope my reaction wouldn't be to take them as logical or any counter-evidence as paradoxical. It's not really a surprise when other cultures, even ones with strong conservative political or cultural strains, produce amazing cinema.

Friday, July 19, 2013

the psychopathology of lying and/or filmmaking in kiarostami's close-up

If I'm going to talk about Close-Up, the 1990 film by Abbas Kiarostami (pretty much Iran's most lauded filmmaker), I'm going to have to talk about a bunch of things I don't actually want to talk about before I can get to what actually interests me.

That's because I only engaged half-heartedly with the film's biggest idea: Close-Up's main thematic strand is the the process and illusion of cinema itself and the artificiality of the movie-making process. The film stems from the story of Hossein Sabzian, an Iranian who (in real life) passed himself off as well-known filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf to a Tehran family of some means, the Ahankhahs. (As an American, I don't know how classy they were by the standards of Iran in 1990, but they have a kempt house and a gated courtyard.)

Sabzian was arrested after his lie was uncovered, and a large chunk of the movie consists of his trial, in the form of a documentary. This footage is interlarded with stagings of his interactions with the Ahankhahs — which, strangely, are acted out by Sabzian and the family themselves. In fact, as Godfrey Cheshire explains in his Criterion essay on the film, "Contrary to what most first-time viewers assume, none of its scenes are strictly documentary. Not just the reenactments but all the other scenes, too, are at least partly scripted or otherwise contrived by Kiarostami."

Friday, July 12, 2013

how did this get made?: best. test audience. ever.

The basic ingredients of How Did This Get Made?, a fortnightly podcast on the Earwolf network, are not promising if you're looking for a nuanced film critique. For each regular episode, three actor-comedians are joined by a guest to ridicule a single bad movie. Ostensibly, the show has no higher purpose than to talk about how awful that film is, which just sounds like a recipe for cheap shots and little-to-no actual insight into what makes a film terrible.

But How Did This Get Made? is probably my single favorite movie podcast. On top of being very funny, HDTGM makes very specific and valid criticisms, and it ends up doing a much better job than many amateur (or even professional) critics in analyzing what has gone wrong. In short, Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, and Jason Mantzoukas are possibly the best test audience of all time.

Friday, May 31, 2013

leviathan has a really subtle point if i think really hard about it

Last year, the New York Times ran a profile of the filmmakers behind Leviathan, which I just saw on Monday. Here's how the profile began:

Tucked within the syllabus for a class that the filmmaker and anthropologist Lucien Castaing-Taylor teaches at Harvard is a rhetorical question that sums up his view of nonfiction film: "If life is messy and unpredictable, and documentary is a reflection of life, should it not be digressive and open-ended too?"

Just so you know, I cannot in good conscience recommend Leviathan, as I was tempted to walk out of the theater due to boredom. That said, this aphorism from Castaing-Taylor does not even make the best case for the film, and of the reviews I've read, I haven't seen anybody else do it, either.

Friday, May 10, 2013

the great gatsby as a test case for what we lose in adaptation; not a post in which i grumble about the superiority of any medium over another, i promise

Greg Olear, writing for The Weeklings, makes a good argument that Nick Carraway, the narrator of The Great Gatsby, is gay. I'm a sucker for unlikely theories about books and movies, but even more so when they rely on a close reading of the evidence. Also, since Baz Luhrmann's movie adaptation of The Great Gatsby is finally coming out this week, Olear's argument has gotten me thinking about the fundamental differences between the art of film and the art of writing.

Before I get to that, I'll have to convey to you the gist of Olear's argument, especially the way he uses Nick's point of view to make it. A big chunk of Olear's evidence comes from the way Carraway describes each of the other five major characters in the novel. Part of the argument comes from how Nick casts a pretty detached eye on the women, even though they are all supposed to be desirable in their own way. As an example, there is a passage where Nick describes Jordan Baker (a golfer), the woman he gets involved with: "She was a slender, small-breasted girl, with an erect carriage, which she accentuated by throwing her body backward at the shoulders like a young cadet." Olear summarizes it this way: "Other than the word small-breasted — which de-emphasizes the golfer's feminine attributes — this could be a description of a man."

Friday, April 12, 2013

the opaque camera in boudu saved from drowning

I've seen three films by Jean Renoir at this point, and I'd rather not say it, but to tell the truth I don't get why he's revered among directors.

The first two that I saw were the ones he's best known for, Grand Illusion and The Rules of the Game, and I didn't dislike them so much as I didn't understand why I needed to watch them. I'll use a painfully vague term on the condition that I promise I won't get in the habit: Both movies seemed a bit unfocused to me.

And so it is with this most recent film of his that I've just seen, Boudu Saved From Drowning, from 1932. Boudu is homeless and living in Paris. After losing his dog, he wanders a bit, seeming not particularly to have any emotion about the loss. And then, wandering across a bridge, he walks to the railing and jumps off into the water. With a telescope, a Monsieur Lestingois sees this and rushes from his nearby bookstore to jump in the river and save Boudu. After a kind of CPR that looks suspiciously like forcing the victim to do calisthenics, Lestingois succeeds in reviving the tramp, and now the bourgeois bookseller feels compelled to look after him. Boudu effectively becomes an unwilling member of the household, joining the aging Lestingois, his wife, and their maid — who is also the older man's mistress.

Friday, April 5, 2013

spring breakers: pathological innocence

I was thinking that Spring Breakers was going to be a certain kind of film. The trailer is all about glossy beach bodies and neon colors and sex and violence, and I assumed the movie would rub my nose in sensationalism, in a kind of cinematic equivalent of saying, "Hey, aren't you cheap for enjoying this lurid stuff?"

I don't suspect this of all lurid movies — some movies are merely tawdry, not self-consciously tawdry in a way that suggests the director is messing with you. But the last film by Breakers' writer-director, Harmony Korine, was a movie about people dressed in completely unconvincing old-people masks and humping trash. Its title was "Trash Humpers." I didn't see it because it looked as though its entire raison d'ĂȘtre was to make me uncomfortable and probably bored.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

game of thrones succumbs to the omar principle (a principle i have just made up)

I'm not a big TV person. I watched the first two episodes of Mad Men and was not compelled to continue; I watched the first three episodes of The Sopranos and was not compelled to continue. I have liked but am now bored with Dexter. You see my point.

Then there's Game of Thrones, coming back for its third season on HBO on March 31. The first two seasons closely followed (I'm assured by my friends) the first two of the five books by George R.R. Martin, so after binge-watching the first two seasons last year, I was up to speed enough to plow through the third, fourth and fifth books.

I don't read a lot of fantasy, and I don't watch a lot of HBO shows or cable in general, so I've been thinking about what makes GoT so particularly addictive for me. Besides for being fantasy, Game of Thrones is like a lot of other cable dramas, insofar as it doesn't punish their characters for being immoral or amoral. Put another way, people get away with murder, rape, and all sorts of lesser evils, and fairly noxious characters occupy central roles and might even be seen as sympathetic.

Monday, February 4, 2013

some blathering re: silver linings playbook, wherein i validate the swoopy cam of david o. russell

It's hard to pinpoint why David O. Russell's movies are so good. He tends to do projects that could be described in generic terms, but then he does a version that seems to transcendent the genre. The Fighter is a great sports movie, Three Kings is a war movie that makes the whole war movie thing seem fresh, and Flirting with Disaster might be my single favorite rom-com.

So I recently checked out Russell's Silver Linings Playbook, even though the previews made it look like a somewhat rote drama. Though the story was middling, the acting justified the attention (though maybe not the Oscar noms). Bradley Cooper doesn't overplay the whole bipolar thing, and in one scene Jennifer Lawrence convincingly stares down Robert De Niro (also great), which is nothing to sneeze at.

But the aspect worth the most analysis hasn't really gotten much notice at all, as far as I can see.

Monday, January 14, 2013

maybe there's a good reason to rip on django unchained, or maybe not, i can't tell

You know, just because I love Quentin Tarantino doesn't mean I don't want to hear criticisms of him. I do; I genuinely enjoy hearing what people think about movies and why they don't like them. That said, the sophist in me wants you to make the best argument possible, even if it's against a piece of art I happen to like.

photo by Steve Rhodes under cc

To begin with, if you're going to criticize Quentin Tarantino for using the n-word too much, you should probably wait until he's doing a movie that isn't about slavery, since QT has already nicely answered your concerns about Django Unchained:

Personally, I find [the criticism] ridiculous. Because it would be one thing if people are out there saying, "You use it much more excessively in this movie than it was used in 1858 in Mississippi." Well, nobody's saying that. And if you're not saying that, you're simply saying I should be lying. I should be watering it down. I should be making it more easy to digest.